Sunday, August 15, 2010

Half a Cheer for Haaretz. If That.

This morning’s Haaretz has an only too revealing editorial.  The editors are “troubled” by statements by the IDF’s chief of staff, Gabi Ashkenazi, concerning the lessons of the Israeli attack on the ship carrying goods to Gaza in defiance of the Israeli siege and blockade, an attack that killed nine Turkish civilians.  It is worth quoting from the editorial at some length:

“Ashkenazi said that for him the main lesson from the operational aspect is that if the Israel Defense Forces confronts a similar scenario in the future, it will have to use snipers, which he says would prevent harm to soldiers. This is very serious and shows that the chief of staff and the IDF have not learned a single lesson from the flotilla affair and Operation Cast Lead.The implication of the chief of staff's words is that the IDF will not hesitate to hit civilians from a distance, using snipers firing live rounds….This was precisely the doctrine of Cast Lead: minimum military casualties at nearly any cost - sometimes harming civilians and ignoring the laws of war. For this Israel continues to pay a heavy international price, and now it turns out that the chief of staff is threatening to continue this doctrine.”

The editorial concludes:

“In the future, similar flotillas must be handled precisely the opposite way.  First, we should ask whether there is a need… [for] a forceful takeover, if we know that the passengers on the ships are not carrying weapons destined for the Gaza Strip.  Even if a forceful takeover is decided on, the IDF will have to find ways to ensure minimum casualties among both the soldiers and passengers….It’s not only about Israel’s image in the media, but also about the ethical profile of the state and its army.”

Note that even Israel’s most liberal newspaper, its acclaimed voice of what remains of Israeli reason, morality, and self-criticism, does not question whether Israel has any right at all to continue its occupation, repression and economic siege of the people of Gaza.  On the contrary, it starts from the premise that Israel has both the right and need to blockade even civilian goods—just that it shouldn’t use force in that case, or at least not if its soldiers enforcing the blockade are not in danger. 

And, by further implication, the restrictions on the use of force are even further relaxed if the ships are carrying weapons.  Weapons, that is, that are intended to fight the Israeli occupation.  You know, like the clandestine weapons flow to the Zionist movement during the 1940s,  designed to resist the British occupation and establish an independent Jewish state.

What accounts for this astonishing moral blindness, all the more painful considering its source as well as its concern about the “ethical profile” of Israel?   Two possibilities suggest themselves: either the editorialists share in the blindness, or they fear that if they question not only the methods but the purpose of the Israeli occupation and blockade, they will lose any chance of convincing their fellow countrymen to reconsider the Israeli occupation and blockade of the Palestinians.

Either way, it is hard to find reasons for optimism about the future of such a society.


Juan said...

Ha'aretz has increasing become a mouthpiece for the Israeli government over at least the past several months. It appears that BDS and other externally initiated actions will be needed to effect movement toward rationality and social justice.

DICKERSON3870 said...

RE: "...either the editorialists share in the blindness, or they fear that if they question not only the methods but the purpose of the Israeli occupation and blockade, they will lose any chance of convincing their fellow countrymen to reconsider the Israeli occupation and blockade of the Palestinians." - Slater
MY GUESS: I often wonder about this myself. I think the latter explanation is more likely to be the correct one.

Harlan said...

I agree with Juan. Since the Anat Kamm-Uri Blau story broke, the editorial balance of Ha'aretz has shifted perceptibly in the government's favor.

Microsoft Office 2010 said...

We are professional of saling Download microsoft office software with Microsoft Office 2010,Microsoft Office 2007 and windows 7 for every body using in their company,we will provide with microsoft office 2007 with free download,provide with Office 2010 low price and Windows 7 for Windows 7 Home Premium,Windows 7 Ultimate, Win 7 Professional and so on.Enjoy your every day from our online software store!

Microsoft Office 2007 is fast approaching and many are asking questions whether it is worth upgrading. It is not cheap to upgrade to 2007 for the purpose of making the move you need to know exactly what the differences are to be and what are the benefits of Microsoft 2007. This article describes some of the key differences you should know to help you make the right decision when you upgrade or not. MS Office 2007 brought the introduction of the tape that is the menu bar at the top of the screen. While there was little he began to develop using it because they left the menu bar button that was so prominent in the predecessors. It has become essential to the use of Microsoft Office and has become much more practical for users once the learning curve has been overcome.

The biggest upgrade to Office 2007 is the increased use of new menu system. Microsoft Office 2007
has used this tape successfully and has been based on that stretch across all the range of products including Outlook and OneNote, which before were still using a menu system more. The new film, which was blue in Download Office 2007
is now a standard white in Office 2007 Professional
, but you can easily change what you prefer. Initially you will have the white tape but you can still change the style of the old button if you have not liked the new style.

With the release of Office 2007
in late 2009 has meant that Download Office 2007 did not use all the features of the new OS. The new features of Office 2007 Professional using the new platform with a new set of icons to be read along the taskbar so you can switch between. You can also see previews of the work to find what you are working by simply moving the cursor on the icon of the MS Office 2007